I really like the product... My complaint is that the t-shirt sizes seem to run extremely small. My daughter is typically a women's-medium, and I had to return it for a women's-XL. And, I'm not even sure about that. I'm sure a men's-medium would have be ok, except for the sleeve and shirt length. You did, however, make the return process very simple, and that is why I'd go with the '8'. Thank you!